11 November 2026
by Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP

Shirley-Anne Somerville: failing to invest in people stores up greater costs for the future

You may be one of the more than two million people who has received support through Scotland's social security system. Or you may never have needed that support at all. You might not think of yourself as the type of person who would ever need social security – but none of us can predict what lies ahead.

Life can change quickly. A new baby is on the way, a condition causes sudden health deterioration, caring responsibilities emerge, or circumstances shift in ways we never expected. That is why social security matters. Even if you do not need it today, it is there should your circumstances change tomorrow.

Like the NHS, it is one of the foundations of a modern society: a service we hope we never need, but one we are all better off having.

When social security enters political debate, the discussion often centres on spending. Questions are asked about affordability, budgets and rising costs. These are legitimate questions. Every pound of public money should be spent wisely and governments should always be able to demonstrate value for money.

But there is another question we should ask: what happens if we fail to invest in people when they need support?

What happens when a disabled person cannot access the support required to live independently? What happens when unpaid carers receive no recognition for the contribution they make? What happens when families facing hardship are left without help, or when children grow up in poverty with fewer opportunities than their peers? These costs do not disappear. They simply emerge elsewhere.

That's understandable. In challenging economic times, people rightly expect governments to spend public money carefully and demonstrate value for every pound invested.

But cost alone is the wrong measure of success.

The reality is that failing to invest in people stores up greater costs for the future. Pressure falls elsewhere – on health services, local authorities, communities and families themselves. Poverty, poor health and inequality place unsustainable burdens and pressure on public services, communities and families. Poverty damages opportunities, worsens health outcomes and limits economic potential. The consequences can last a lifetime.

That is why Scotland has chosen a different approach to social security – we view social security not as a burden, but as an investment in people.

An investment in children having the best possible start in life. An investment in disabled people being able to participate fully in society. An investment in supporting carers, reducing poverty and improving wellbeing. And ultimately, an investment in the social and economic strength of our country.

This isn't simply about helping people through difficult moments, important though that is. It is about recognising that a fairer society benefits everyone.

Too often the public conversation focuses on those who receive support today and overlooks a simple truth: social security is part of the foundation of a modern society. It provides security when life becomes uncertain and reassurance that support is available when circumstances change.

Of course, investing in social security is only one part of the story. How that support is delivered matters too. Over the last eight years, Scotland has built a social security system designed around dignity, fairness and respect. That means recognising that people accessing support are not statistics or case numbers. They are individuals with families, ambitions and challenges of their own.

It means making services easier to access, improving take-up so people receive the support to which they are entitled, and listening to those with lived experience to improve how services operate. It also means being honest about where improvements are needed and that includes ensuring money is only paid to people eligible to receive it.

No public service is perfect. There will always be opportunities to do better, whether through enhanced capabilities to detect fraud and error or harnessing technology to improve processes making our service fit for the future.

But we should also be willing to recognise success.

Hundreds of thousands of people including pensioners, carers and disabled people  have transferred safely into Scotland's social security system from the DWP. New benefits have been introduced to address poverty and inequality.

There will always be political disagreements about social security. Public spending should be scrutinised, and governments should be challenged to demonstrate outcomes and value for money.

However, we should be cautious about viewing every discussion solely through the lens of expenditure. The true measure of social security is not simply what it costs. It is what it achieves.

A family avoids falling into poverty; a disabled person can remain in work or a carer receives support that eases financial pressure – this is why social security is an investment in people.

An investment in healthier lives and stronger communities.

An investment in the kind of country we want Scotland to be.

Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP is cabinet secretary for social justice and housing.

Social security is one of Scotland's most important investments - TFN

The above information is from a Third Force News (TFN) Weekly Social Justice and Poverty roundup Newsletter Tue 17/11/2026